In 1634, the merchant ship Saardam prepares to sail from Batavia to Amsterdam when a leper delivers a terrifying warning: a demon called Old Tom has cursed the ship, and everyone aboard is doomed. Moments later, the man bursts into flames. Stranger still, he had no tongue and should never have been able to speak. Despite the warning, the ship departs, carrying wealthy merchants, powerful officials, and the celebrated detective Samuel Pipps, who is mysteriously travelling as a prisoner. Soon, the leper’s prophecy appears to come true. Strange symbols appear, animals are slaughtered, and passengers hear a disembodied voice promising to fulfil their deepest desires in exchange for obedience. When a seemingly impossible murder occurs behind a locked door, panic spreads. Has the devil himself boarded the Saardam?
With Pipps imprisoned, his loyal companion Arent Hayes takes up the investigation alongside Sara Wessel, the intelligent wife of the powerful governor-general Jan Haan. They are joined by Sara’s daughter Lia, a gifted young inventor with a remarkable talent for solving mechanical puzzles, and Creesjie, a resourceful noblewoman whose courage and quick thinking make her a valuable ally. Together, they uncover dark connections between the passengers, reaching years into the past. Old Tom’s threats seem strangely personal, his appearances suspiciously calculated. Someone aboard knows the passengers’ most carefully guarded secrets. But who could orchestrate such elaborate horrors, and why? As suspicion turns to violence and the ship approaches disaster, Arent and Sara begin to suspect that the devil’s greatest trick may be convincing everyone he exists.
The truth is more sinister than any supernatural explanation. Old Tom is an elaborate deception orchestrated by Creesjie, whose real name is Emily de Haviland, and her brother Hugo, the celebrated detective Samuel Pipps. Years earlier, their family was destroyed by a corrupt witch-hunting conspiracy involving Jan Haan, and the siblings have spent years plotting revenge. With the help of accomplices, they manufactured the haunting, manipulated the passengers, and engineered Haan’s seemingly impossible murder. But their vengeance spirals beyond control, leaving innocent people dead and the Saardam destroyed, and whatever’s left of the crew and passengers stranded on an island. When the truth finally emerges, Sara proposes an unexpected solution: preserve the legend of Old Tom and use it to punish powerful people who escape justice. What began as a terrifying supernatural mystery ends with an unsettling revelation: the devil was human all along.
Fav Scenes/Snippets
‘How do I look?’ asked Sammy, turning on the spot.
‘Like you spent the night with an ox.’
‘I didn’t want your mother to be the only one.’
(page 136)
What happens on the poop deck hopefully doesn’t stay on the poop deck
Arent and Sammy discussing a murder investigation while Sammy takes a dump is peak literature, and I refuse to be mature about it.
‘I must attend my ablutions.’
‘Just go, it’s nothing I haven’t –’
‘Arent, please,’ he exclaimed. ‘I have very little dignity left, and I’d like to keep hold of what remains.’
Sighing, Arent turned his back.
Sammy yanked down his breeches, sticking his arse over the water.
‘The governor general is a dangerous man,’ he groaned as excrement poured out of him, splashing in the sea. ‘I’ve tried to spare you his scrutiny, so tell me, for my own peace of mind, why would he agree to let me out of that cell?’
My Thoughts & Review
In all seriousness, I found it an incredibly easy and entertaining read. The characters were lovable, the mystery kept me intrigued, and some scenes genuinely made me laugh out loud.
What surprised me most, though, was Sara. It’s rare that I come across a female character written by a male author who feels so real. Her desires, frustrations, and motivations were wonderfully convincing, and her actions always felt perfectly aligned with who she was and what she wanted. Her rebelliousness and desire for freedom were things I could relate to, while her compassion and warmth made her endearing.
Interesting tidbit: Turton mentions in the author’s notes that Sara was his favourite character to write. I believe he proved it by writing her so well.
My one small disappointment was the ending. I couldn’t help thinking how much fun it would have been to get an epilogue showing the characters actually working together as a band of unlikely vigilantes, travelling the world and bringing corrupt people to justice. After everything they’d been through, I would have loved one last glimpse of their adventures.
All in all, a wonderful read. I wouldn’t call it one of the best books I’ve ever read, but it was thoroughly enjoyable, with memorable characters, a clever mystery, and plenty of charm. I’d happily recommend it to anyone looking for a good book to get lost in for a while.








Leave a Reply